Startup roast
You've told the story a hundred times and it lands every time in person. Then someone visits the website cold and understands none of it. That gap is what this finds.
No account. No card. One free roast per website.
The curse of knowing your own product
You cannot un-know what your company does, which means you can't read your own homepage the way a stranger reads it. Every sentence looks clear because you're supplying the missing context for free. Your visitors aren't.
Startup clichés, named and counted
Revolutionize, disrupt, empower, unleash, next-generation, reimagine, seamless, game-changing. None of them are crimes on their own. Stacked four deep in a hero section, they signal that the page is avoiding a plain statement — and readers notice, even when they can't articulate why the page feels empty.
- Claims with no evidence attached ('10x faster' with no baseline).
- A category claim that names no incumbent.
- Team-of-ex-FAANG social proof standing in for customer social proof.
- 'Coming soon' on the same page as a monthly price.
Nuclear goes after the strategy
The $3.99 tier isn't the $1.99 tier with more words. It goes after the business model, the category claim, and the distance between what the page promises and what has evidently been built. If there's a strategic mistake sitting underneath all the surface ones, that's the tier that names it.
Fair warning
We roast the website, the product and the claims. Never the founder, the team, or anyone personally. That's a hard rule, and it's also why the feedback is usable — an insult aimed at you is useless, an observation aimed at your headline is a to-do item.
When to get roasted
The two highest-value moments are the week before you launch and the week after a rewrite. Before launch, everything is still cheap to change and nobody has formed an opinion of you yet. After a rewrite, the score movement is the only cheap read you will get on whether the rewrite actually worked — you cannot judge that yourself, because you now know the new copy as well as you knew the old.
- Pre-launch: fix the headline while changing it costs an afternoon rather than a repositioning.
- Post-rewrite: compare scores to find out whether you improved the page or just changed it.
- Before a fundraise: investors read the site before the deck, and they read it cold.
- After a pivot, when the page usually still sells the previous company.
Want us to go deeper?
The free one was us being polite. These are not.
How much pain can you take?
Brutal
Most people pick thisOkay, you asked for this.
We'll find what you were hoping nobody would notice.
- Design
- Copy
- Calls to action
- Pricing
- Positioning
- Trust
10–15 observations
Questions
Is this useful pre-launch?
Especially then. A roast before launch costs $0.99 and a bad launch costs considerably more attention than that.
Can I share the result with my co-founder?
That is the intended use. The result page has a public link and a share card designed to survive being pasted into Slack.
What if my site is genuinely good?
Then you'll get a lower roast score, a shorter roast, and a note about what's working. The scoring runs the other way from what you'd expect — high means roastable, not good.
Fine. We'll give you one for free.
First hit's free
One roast. No card. No mercy.
No account. No card. One free roast per website.