Landing page roast

Your landing page has one job and roughly five seconds to do it. This tells you exactly where those five seconds go wrong, with jokes, because a teardown you enjoy reading is a teardown you actually act on.

Takes ~30 seconds ยท Your roast stays private unless you publish it

No account. No card. One free roast per website.

The five-second test, run properly

The standard advice is 'show it to a stranger for five seconds and ask what it does'. The trouble is that finding strangers is annoying and they're polite. This does the same test, reports the answer without tact, and tells you which element caused the confusion.

The mistakes that show up most

Across a lot of landing pages, the same handful of failures account for most of the damage โ€” and almost all of them are fixable in an afternoon.

  • A headline that describes a category rather than a customer and a job.
  • Three competing CTAs above the fold, so the page asks for three decisions before earning one.
  • Features listed as capabilities ('real-time sync') with no outcome attached.
  • Social proof that names no one.
  • Pricing hidden behind 'contact sales' on a product that plainly costs $29 a month.
  • A hero section a full viewport tall containing eleven words.

Structure gets read too

Not just the words. Section order, how many times the same card layout repeats, whether the navigation has eight items and three of them say 'Product', how far a visitor has to scroll before anything concrete appears. Structure is where a lot of pages leak without anyone noticing.

What you get back

A roast score, a set of specific observations grouped by category, six meters, a verdict, and one sincere recommendation. It's built to be screenshotted, which is a design constraint that also happens to make it easy to send to whoever owns the copy.

Want us to go deeper?

The free one was us being polite. These are not.

How much pain can you take?

Brutal

Most people pick this

Okay, you asked for this.

We'll find what you were hoping nobody would notice.

  • Design
  • Copy
  • Calls to action
  • Pricing
  • Positioning
  • Trust

10โ€“15 observations

Questions

Do you check the pricing page too?

At Brutal and Nuclear, yes โ€” we read a small bounded set of same-domain pages including /pricing when they exist.

Will it help with conversion rate?

It finds the clarity and trust problems that suppress conversion. It isn't an A/B testing tool and won't promise you a percentage.

Can I roast the same page twice?

Yes, and after a rewrite that's a genuinely useful thing to do โ€” the score movement tells you whether the rewrite worked.

Fine. We'll give you one for free.

First hit's free

One roast. No card. No mercy.

Takes ~30 seconds ยท Your roast stays private unless you publish it

No account. No card. One free roast per website.

Landing Page Roast โ€” Find Out Why It Isn't Converting | PayToRoast